The ODP mentorship process helps to guide new editors as they learn the sometimes complex process of categorizing sites. A couple of weeks ago, we heard from editor Laigh who called out his role as a mentor as one of the highlights of his experience. Today, we hear from Snooks, one of Laigh's pupils, about the experience of being mentored.
- - - - - - - - -
My name is Snooks and I have been an editor for about six months.
I remember the day that I got the email indicating I had been accepted. I was so excited! The first time i logged in, looking at my dashboard, I was pretty nervous. It has links to here, there and everywhere. It's actually quite daunting at first. I didn't know what to do!
I spent some time looking at the forums and then I posted in the New Editors Thread. I conversed with a few editors and felt sort of ok. I was still very nervous, still unsure on what I could or couldn't do. I had a look through the category and added the sites from my Editors application, adjusted a few things on other sites and all appeared in order.
There was a thread in the New Editors Section, titled "Editors' School - Mentorship Program." Reading the posts I could see that you applied to the school and an experienced editor would then be assigned to assist you. The editor would be your
The program involved 30 sites being placed in a category especially for you. In my own time, I was to edit the titles and descriptions, indicate where I would place the sites or, in the case of sites that were not suitable, mark them for deletion and explain why. The best part was that I couldn't hurt anything, I couldn't break DMOZ as there are measures in place so that if I made a mistake, the site couldn't be lost. My
Over the next week or so, I edited the sites, communicated with Laigh way too often and finally, the day came when we were both free and he was going to do the review of my sites.
I remember being at my computer in Sydney Australia, Laigh at his in Scotland.....we spoke on live chat and he said he was starting.........I was really, really nervous.
The first site came up:
(Site Name) the words beside it said "ready to go live."
This was followed by 10 or 15 more, at 1 minute intervals.
On the last one, he seemed to take eternity. I waited and waited and remember sending a message saying "Go on....Push the button! You know you want to!"
The message came Back "RAFL - ready to go live"
He detected one or two that needed minor changes such as a tweak on the description or a spelling mistake. But that was great news.......out of the 30 sites, 26 were live! The other 4 needed minor changes and then those sites would also go live.
I was delighted. I knew then that I really could edit. I really could evaluate and review a site and be trusted to ensure compliance with guidelines. This was confirmed when a Meta Editor granted me permissions to edit in a higher level category, that very same night. From my first cat with 25 sites, I now had a cat with 300 sites. I felt 10 feet tall!
I have now done 5600 edits and I have permission to edit in a category with thousands of sites. I know that without my
The Mentor Program instilled me with confidence. I do feel that without the program, I would not have advanced like I have. I may well have been too nervous to become involved enough, to feel comfy and actually enjoy editing. And I do! I really enjoy editing.
Thank you for letting me share this with you.




1. Hi Snooks
Thank you for your post - I enjoyed it, and I'm enjoying hearing more about life inside DMOZ; it's good that DMOZ is coming out of a dark secret world and into the light!
Posted at 4:44AM on Nov 11th 2008 by Gideon
2. @ Gideon
It does sound somewhat mysterious, what with titles such as Metas, Editalls and Cateditalls etc. But in reality, we are just a bunch of normal people, having fun and building a directory whilst surfing the net. ;)
Posted at 11:20PM on Nov 11th 2008 by Snooks
3. Nice tips... thanks for share it...
Posted at 8:35AM on Nov 12th 2008 by Chafid.Com
4. I wish that DMOZ would provide a comprehensive mentoring program, as I've been perplexed about how sites are included or not at the directory. Perhaps there aren't enough editors to handle the load of requests or they may need better mentorship.
At any rate, I've been waiting well over 1 year for a listing for my website after several submissions.
Posted at 12:09PM on Nov 13th 2008 by Henry Rock
5. hi Snooks..
hmm i think i can not do like you do..
but you have great job help all web to be listed,
but poor me i was submited my site and still didnt accepted to be listed in dmoz:(
Posted at 4:10PM on Nov 13th 2008 by sasidesign
6. Nice post. It's always great to hear about developments at DMOZ and seeing the progress that editors and the site in general are making. Keep up the great work!
-Kenneth
Posted at 4:02AM on Nov 15th 2008 by Kenneth Yeh
7. Great job snooks!
This is informative and, I think, a bit inspiring as well. I think a lot of new editors are a bit nervous at the start. By showing us what you have gone through, as well as the progress you've made, I think we get a sense of what we can do if we put our minds to it and ask questions. Mentorship is a 2-way street. "Ask and ye shall receive" and remember... you may need to ask twice.
Posted at 9:26PM on Nov 17th 2008 by scarecrow
8. This is very interesting as well as knowledgeable to those unknown in this domain.
Posted at 9:40AM on Nov 18th 2008 by nishagun
9. I think it's great with a mentor, whatever the subject is. It seem to be a tough job to be an editor. I've been thinking of it before, but since I've been traveling a lot and will continue to travel now and then, it's perhaps not so good idea :-)
Something else: Since I couldn't find any other way to contact you, I do that this way. I've tried to submit my site twice to DMOZ, with long time in between, the latest to the Travel cat. Without luck.
I see no reason for this, so I would really appreciate an answer to WHY my blog isn't accepted. That would be very helpful, since I'm not aware of what it could be that you dislike with it.
I've read the instructions and can't see that I'm doing something wrong either.
Please help, by at least sending me an answer, thanks :-)
Sunny greetings,
Captain Lifecruiser.com
(Lifecruiser Travel Blog)
Posted at 8:13AM on Nov 19th 2008 by Lifecruiser
10. Nice post. It's always great to hear about developments at DMOZ and seeing the progress that editors and the site in general are making. Keep up the great work!
Posted at 1:56AM on Nov 20th 2008 by A7LAM BANOUTA
11. @Lifecruiser: Have you read the previous blog post that addresses this question?
http://blog.dmoz.org/2007/10/08/why-hasnt-my-site-been-accepted-into-dmoz/
You might also find the following (unofficial) FAQ useful:
http://www.resource-zone.com/forum/faq.php?faq=odp#faq_faq_site_questions
Posted at 10:29AM on Nov 20th 2008 by chaos127
12. It is conceivable that many editors, who want to remain as editors for various reasons, would log in once every 4 months and make a single word change here or there just to fulfill the requirement for continuing their editor status.
-------
Adam
Internet marketing
Posted at 4:39AM on Nov 26th 2008 by Adamgilly
13. Great blog!Thank you for your help
Posted at 4:06AM on Dec 2nd 2008 by milos
14. Thank you so mushc for this article... great post
Posted at 8:59AM on Dec 12th 2008 by kenan hudabi
15. i think that this directory is useful and choose the best websites
Posted at 3:49PM on Dec 23rd 2008 by ofir
16. I think also that Dmoz still the best directory, I will submit my little new website
Brian
Posted at 2:05PM on Jan 3rd 2009 by calculatrices.info
17. ..in the case of sites that were not suitable, mark them for deletion and explain why.
How about sending a message to the email of those who submit with the reason? Ain't we looking for a better directory? :)
Posted at 9:10PM on Jan 28th 2009 by Anonymous