When you think of social networking, what names come to mind? For many people, the obvious answers include MySpace, Facebook, Bebo and LinkedIn. But while these may be the heavy-hitters in the Web 2.0 social networking space, they do not represent the only opportunities the Web has to offer.
Directories represent another type of social network that have endured since the days of Web 1.0. People-powered search through directories such as DMOZ has been around for more than a decade, and, despite vast improvements in algorithmic search in the time since their founding, they still play a very vital role in the search world.
But how can search, a seemingly solitary activity, be collaborative? There really are three interdependent social networks that combine to make the whole, and within each these networks, it is the collective knowledge and experience of the community that contributes to the success of the interaction. The three networks include:
- The end user community
- The editor community, and
- The webmaster/site-submitter community
Let's take a closer look at how these work together using as an example a user's query for "eagles." Does the user want information on the West Coast Eagles, an Australian Rules football team? The rock band popular for hits such as Hotel California and Tequila Sunrise? Or does the user want to know more about birds of prey?
An algorithmic engine can make a good guess about the context, but it might not always get it right, especially in cases where the user intends a slightly more obscure result. It is in this type of ambiguous situation, however, where human-powered search can really shine.
If the user turns to a directory to find information about eagles, he or she will be engaging in a dialog of sorts with the editor community. The dialog is not direct, but rather, it is represented by the contextual meaning built into the hand-built category structure. Perhaps the user in our example is actually looking for information on the Fraternal Order of the Eagles, a service organization that operates throughout the and . He or she can simply bypass DMOZ's Sports, Science and Art categories and drill down directly through the Society category to find the desired results.
Behind the scenes, the second social network – the editor community – may have had a lot to do with this users' success. There is a "wisdom of crowds" element within the editor community in which the opinions of many people help to create a clearer directory structure and find better placements for hard to categorize sites than any one editor could do if working alone. Additionally, editors with specific knowledge of a geographic location or subject area may help others to place sites into the appropriate locations within the directory. For example, a new editor may have consulted the community for help to determine whether the Fraternal Order of the Eagles was better suited to be grouped with Clubs & Lodges or Organizations.
Through the final network, the webmasters/site-submitters, thousands of site suggestions are routed to the appropriate editors who sort them to determine if and where they should be included in the directory.




1. Sorry for hijacking this thread in order to contact DMOZ but an important part of your site appears to be broken and I could not find another contact means
I tried to update the very old and out of date information about my domain - thealders.net - and when I hit complete I got the following error message
Proxy Error
The proxy server received an invalid response from an upstream server.
The proxy server could not handle the request POST /cgi-bin/update3.cgi.
Reason: Error reading from remote server
Posted at 2:54AM on Dec 14th 2008 by Doug Alder
2. I am unable to suggest a URL. When I do I get this error:
Proxy Error
The proxy server received an invalid response from an upstream server.
The proxy server could not handle the request GET /cgi-bin/add.cgi.
Reason: Error reading from remote server
Posted at 12:52PM on Dec 16th 2008 by rishi
3. DMOZ long ago stopped listening to people and taking suggestions. I have been trying to get our site listed for six years.
Posted at 7:27AM on Dec 17th 2008 by Ian
4. i agree with Ian, been trying to get sites into DMOZ for years, personally I think its because we not 'american'.
Posted at 6:27AM on Dec 20th 2008 by ck
5. thank you...
hit
Posted at 12:54PM on Dec 25th 2008 by hit
6. Hi,
I had 3 times : Internal Server Error
The server encountered an internal error or misconfiguration and was unable to complete your request.
Posted at 11:20AM on Jan 1st 2009 by une-nounou.fr
7. I applied for a three-year period 4 times, but there is no response,
I have carefully read all the rules,
I might have encountered the above people are talking about mistakes?
I think I will succeed! Thank you DMOZ!
Posted at 7:57PM on Jan 5th 2009 by Alex
8. "4. i agree with Ian, been trying to get sites into DMOZ for years, personally I think its because we not 'american'."
I don't believe it has anything to do with being American or not. I am as American as they come and I have been trying for over a year (probably tried to submit over 200 times from different machines and different ISPs, and I can't get my request submitted. I get the proxy error that everyone else is getting.
Posted at 10:07AM on Jan 16th 2009 by John
9. Great to know about this.. thank you..
Posted at 3:22AM on Jan 25th 2009 by julius
10. ok that right...
Posted at 3:22AM on Jan 25th 2009 by myce101.com
11. thank you...
Posted at 6:32PM on Jan 27th 2009 by tomee
12. For me, All social networking sites are just clones.
Maybe only Facebook made some changes, And i think that these changes are the reason why Facebook has become the best social networking site today.
Thanks Emily
Posted at 9:14PM on Jan 28th 2009 by Anonymous